Sterling or Scully: Gary Cohen calls a rare Pete Alonso Home Run

I haven’t checked in on Gary’s PBP for a while.  With Pete Alonso hitting a rare HR (his 12th!) let’s see how Gare is doing.

So here’s the problem Gary. I want to give this call a good grade because the ball is obviously gone off the bat. However the call has a fatal flaw. You said the ball is outta “here.” But the ball is on DC an you are in NYC.

So you’re forcing a catch phrase Gary. And you know who forces catch-phrases? No, not Vin Scully. John Sterling forces catch phrases. And thus there can only be on grade here.

VERDICT: Sterling

Gary – WHY do you force the coach phrase? Do you think it is beloved? Do you think Darren is going to make Outta Here T-Shirts – well that’s not happening since you obviously have an issue with him since you’re the only announcer who doesn’t acknowledged the T-Shirt Army to the point that you go SILENT when the telecast shows them. Are you planning on writing an Outta Here book some day? I don’t get it. You don’t need it and you definitely didn’t need to say it every time. Be better Gary. It’s a net negative to you game.

While we’re doing HR calls, here’s another from Gary Sterling.

Now I don’t know what’s wrong with Gary but since like 2019 I feel like he doesn’t see the ball well. And I get that he’s calling this off the monitor but you know what, I am watching it on twitter and I can see that this isn’t “toward the wall.”

Gary, how the heck is this “towards the wall” – look at this ON THE MONITOR LIKE I AM.

That’s a terrible call Gary. That’s an announcer on auto-pilot saying the words he always says. Be better.

VERDICT: Sterling

The Mets Police
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.