Sterling or Scully: Howie Rose vs. Gary Cohen – Pete Alonso HR

Here’s the same home run called by two announcers.

First up, it’s the best baseball announcer of them all, Howie Rose.

This is an excellent call.  What I love about Howie is his ability to paint a picture with his voice.  You know right away it is a home run.

Verdict:  Scully

Now let’s see how Gary Cohen did.

This is almost a great call.  Like Howie, Gary is not messing around and knows it is gone and tells us so.  However, Gary says it is outta “here” – and Gary was in NYC and the ball is in Atlanta.  So that’s an inaccurate call by someone forcing a catch phrase.  And that makes it a Sterling call.

Verdict:  Sterling.

Winner:  Howie